This article originally appeared on Inside Climate News, a nonprofit, non-partisan news organization that covers climate, energy and the environment. Sign up for their newsletter here.
A Maryland utility is touting a project that allows owners of Ford F-150 Lightning electric pickups to send power from their vehicles to the grid and get compensated for it.
The Baltimore Gas and Electric Co. project is a partnership with Ford, the automaker, and Sunrun, a solar and energy services company. It’s the kind of thing that, if deployed on a large scale, could be transformative for the grid.
But the nagging sense I get when reading about vehicle-to-grid pilot projects is that this is an opportunity that remains largely untapped. The Maryland project, for example, involves just three trucks.
Electric vehicles use the large majority of the lithium-ion batteries being produced in today’s market. When those EV batteries are sitting in garages and connected to chargers, they become a potentially vast resource that can be utilized by the grid, generating income for the vehicles’ owners. But to realize this opportunity, utilities, automakers and regulators need to move beyond pilot projects.
Also, the market share for EVs needs to continue to grow, and the Trump administration’s cancellation of the tax credit of up to $7,500 for buying a new EV is a setback. The tax credit ended this week, and analysts expect it will lead to a decrease in EV sales at least in the short term.
I spoke with Willett Kempton, a University of Delaware professor who first wrote about the potential of vehicle-to-grid power in 1997. That paper, co-authored with Steven E. Letendre, who was then at Green Mountain College in Vermont, had a central idea that seemed almost like science fiction at the time, when EVs barely existed. The paper’s title sums it up: “Electric vehicles as a new power source for electric utilities.”
One of its key points was that the technology for using EVs to power the grid was pretty simple. Consumers would need to have bi-directional chargers, capable of sending electricity from the grid to the battery, and from the battery to the grid. And grid managers would need software to control the flow of electricity to the grid.
Kempton found that groups of EVs could send power to the grid and receive compensation that would help to offset the costs of owning the vehicle. There would be almost no negative effect on battery life or the vehicle’s readiness for use.
“The economics are really compelling,” he said.
Here’s some of the math he found exciting: If the United States could get to the point that one-fourth of its vehicles were EVs with bi-directional chargers, they would provide the grid with access to 660 gigawatts of capacity. That figure, from a 2005 paper he co-authored, was close to the total capacity of all U.S. power plants at that time. Since then, other researchers have conducted their own versions of this calculation using more recent variables, underscoring the vast potential.
The main stumbling block turned out to be the reluctance of various stakeholders to agree on technical standards so that they would all be speaking the equivalent of the same language regarding how the system controls would work.
Only recently, decades after that 1997 paper, are companies involved in vehicle-to-grid technology beginning to adopt common charging standards. Now that the standards are coming into place, automakers and utilities have a much easier time setting up vehicle-to-grid programs than they would have before.
Progress is now happening with the development of laws and rules in the states and with pilot projects by companies such as Nuvve of San Diego, a leading player in vehicle-to-grid technology.
Nuvve’s U.S. projects include managing power from a fleet of electric buses in the Cajon Valley Union School District in the San Diego area.
At least eight states have recently enacted or introduced legislation or regulatory actions to foster vehicle-to-grid technology, according to the NC Clean Energy Technology Center. They are: California, Connecticut, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Massachusetts and New Jersey.
Delaware has been at the forefront, including the work of Kempton and his colleagues at the University of Delaware. Researchers there, sometimes in partnership with the utility Delmarva Power, have used vehicles from Nissan, BMW and other makers as part of various pilot projects.
One recurring theme across the states is that electric buses and fleet vehicles are a common early step for vehicle-to-grid technology because the batteries are large and they are often parked in a central location, making them easier to manage.
What I don’t see anywhere are projects with hundreds or thousands of residential EVs. In this way, vehicle-to-grid initiatives are not as far along as some of the efforts involving home battery systems used in virtual power plants, which are groups of batteries that work together to function like a power plant. Sunrun is a key player in virtual power plants and it has several vehicle-to-grid projects, including the one in Maryland.
Sunrun describes the Maryland initiative as the first in the country to use residential vehicles, as opposed to commercial or fleet vehicles. Last week, it announced that the vehicles had successfully sent power to the grid, after about a year of setting up systems to allow this to happen.
“In addition to showing how electric vehicles can power homes, add electrons to the grid, and help utilities meet peak electricity demand, this program also creates extra income opportunities for customers,” said Sunrun CEO Mary Powell in a statement.
Beginning in July, the utility had the ability to use power from the trucks during the peak demand hours of 5 p.m. to 9 p.m. on weekdays. The vehicles’ owners get paid based on the amount of electricity they share, which caps at $1,000 for a period that ran from July to September, Sunrun said.
Sunrun has been working with Ford to develop programs such as the one in Baltimore. The long-term goal is to make it commonplace for an EV owner to be able to use their vehicle’s battery for backup power at home or as an income source by selling power to the grid.
Some of the most significant developments in vehicle-to-grid technology are happening in Europe. BMW announced a program last month in Germany where consumers could receive essentially free charging at home in exchange for allowing their battery to provide power to the grid when it’s connected to a charger.
In 1997, Kempton expected that this technology would be much further along than it is today.
“I thought the world was going to beat a path,” he said.
But he is optimistic that today’s pilot projects indicate a market on the cusp of something big. He notes that most of the new EVs coming onto the market have built-in capability for bi-directional charging, and many utilities are in some phase of integrating this into their grid management.
So, let’s see a utility do a vehicle-to-grid project with hundreds or even thousands of vehicles. And let’s see it soon.